From Keane to Kyrgiakos, Alonso to Aquilani...

The 'Rafalution' has certainly gone under the microscope at the minute and the media seem ever so keen to highlight his poor signings. Now, I'm not going to defend some of his signings as I'm sure you would agree that Nunez, Josemi and Kromkamp sent most fans into a cold sweat everytime they made an appearance. However, when considering some of his poor signings against the flops bought by other top 4 managers, you will realise the media are being a little unfair.

Yes I could give a mention to Fergie, Wenger and Abramovich/Kenyon's flops too. Crespo, Shevchenko and Veron or Kleberson, Djemba-Djemba and Taibi are all far worse signings than some of Rafa's and a whole lot more costlier too. However, Rafa seems to bring a lot of criticism on himself. His stubborn persistence with players such as Lucas Leiva (who's birth certificate I would like to see) separates him from the rest. If Ferguson makes a mistake, they are almost always sold on, more often than not for profit I hasten to add. The same with Chelsea to a degree, if a player is just simply not good enough, he will be sold, or in the case of Hernan Crespo be loaned out for about 3 years! Chelsea don't have to worry about flops as much however due to their unrivalled wealth, or at least it was unrivalled until Manchester City's owners graced our shores. It is this where I feel Rafa is being a little harshly treated. His 'eye for talent' is something that is also frequently challenged. I can assure you that there is nothing wrong with his eye for talent, he just does not have the financial means to always sign who he wants. It is for that reason that he ends up signing second or third choice players who are often gambles. Inevitably, gambles do not always pay off. Rafa has identified David Villa, David Silva, Daniel Alves, Simao Sabrosa, Sergio Aguero (before he signed for Atletico) amongst others as potential signings so there is nothing wrong with his eye for talent. However, when Rick Parry was at the helm and our worrying financial situation these were unrealistic targets. Instead he ended up with Jermaine Pennant, who was deemed to not be good enough for Arsenal yet we signed anyway, as well as Mark González, Fernando Morientes and Andriy Voronin.

Benitez has more often than not got it right when he has been able to spend big although he has had to sell before he can buy in the summer gone by. Can people really argue with the signings of a certain striker named Fernando Torres? How about Pepe Reina, Xabi Alonso, Javier Mascherano, Daniel Agger and Glen Johnson? I'm sure regardless of who you support you would not be disappointed to see anyone of these on your club's team sheet. Furthermore, he's trying to restructure the youth academy which, in my opinion, was long overdue. Although I'm not sure whether he should be getting involved in this area of the club, things certainly seem to be improving. As Gerard Houllier once said regarding the academy, 'I'm not expecting the next Steven Gerrard, but I wouldn't mind a few Jamie Carraghers.' Or something along those lines. I feel Rafa has echoed those sentiments, and although there will never be another Steven Gerrard, he is slowly introducing one or two young players who are most definitely prospects. Martin Kelly's man of the match performance on his debut against Olympique Lyonnais shows this. Furthermore, Jay Spearing made his debut in a home tie against Real Madrid. Gone are the days of rolling out McManaman's, Fowler's and Owen's year after year, but it's a step in the right direction.

Although it may appear hard to believe, I'm not so pro-Rafa that I would defend him whatever happens. Six defeats in a season that is still only in October is by no way good enough. However, as I may just have mentioned once or twice, we are rather struggling somewhat in terms of finance. Would it really be wise to sack him at the cost of around £20m? Because that is the sort of figure he would get as he only signed his latest deal on the 18th March 2009. Then a new guy comes in with a whole array of new ideas that would probably take another 5 years to implement fully and by that time Gerrard ad Carragher will either be gone or well past their best. I guess what I am trying to say is that it was only a few months ago that Rafa led us to four points from winning the title and although Alonso has gone, not much else has changed.

Mark Jepson